Trump's Tough-on-China Talk Was Always Just an Act

By Mona Charen

November 20, 2026 8 min read

Don't you wish you could administer truth serum to Laura Ingraham, Steve Bannon or the dozens of other Trumpists who proclaimed their belief in Trump's "toughness" on the People's Republic of China? Remember how they used to talk? In 2019, the late Lou Dobbs opened his broadcast one night on Fox Business this way:

"For far too long Communist China has been cheating the United States on trade. President Trump has made it clear: The failure of previous presidents to aggressively represent U.S. interests in foreign policy and economic policy has ended, and President Trump made believers out of the Chinese today."

Trump's rhetoric on "Chy-na" was feverish. They were waging "economic war" on us. They were "raping" our country. They were sending us the "China virus" or the "Kung Flu." Trump's supposed hawkishness on China was a selling point with working-class men. Here was a foreign scapegoat for the loss of manufacturing jobs. The focus on China justified a whole school of foreign policy advisers, led by Elbridge Colby, currently the undersecretary of defense for policy, joined by Pete Hegseth, JD Vance, Josh Hawley and Ron DeSantis, who favored limiting assistance to Ukraine in the name of keeping our powder dry for China.

What do these faux-hawks really think as they contemplate Trump's upcoming summit with Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin and (if Trump can swing it) Kim Jong-un? That he's tough? Good God.

The West prevailed over the Communist world in the Cold War for many reasons — communism makes countries poorer, for one thing-but a key factor was our superior technology. We maintained that dominance by export controls to keep American-derived knowledge out of the hands of those who wished us ill.

We are not today in a Cold War with China, but China is the most powerful repressive country on the planet, and one whose propaganda ceaselessly agitates against the U.S. The China hawks are right to be wary of China, though wrong in just about every other way.

But Trump, hyperventilating threats notwithstanding, is not a China hawk, nor is he a dove. Those categories don't apply to him, because they imply an interest in policy and in the nation. Trump doesn't make decisions that way. His chief focus — and, frankly, his only real concern-can be found in the shaving mirror.

The Nvidia scandal (I'm referring to the Trump administration's actions, not the honey trap) is merely the capstone on the second-term pattern.

Like most bullies, Trump kisses up and punches down. As soon as someone punches back, Trump becomes a toothless crocodile. The pattern held with China. After imposing up to nearly 150% tariffs on Chinese goods on "Liberation Day," Trump found that China was not, in fact, down. It struck back with export limits on rare earths. Trump was flummoxed.

As Anja Manuel, a former State Department official, told the Wall Street Journal, China "stood up to President Trump with the rare earths, and the U.S. backed down." Trump quietly reversed several of the tariffs and then announced the result as a great "deal" after meeting with Xi.

Trump was more blase about threats from China than most members of the Republican and Democratic parties were. In 2024, large majorities of both parties voted for the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act, a law that would require TikTok, a Chinese-owned company subject to state controls, to be sold. In his first term, Trump had labeled TikTok a grave national security threat, but when he returned to office in January 2025, he (illegally) suspended enforcement of the law. The legislators, and even the Supreme Court, thought the app was a propaganda arm of the PRC and had concerns about the data it was collecting from its tens of millions of American users. But Trump apparently did his usual analysis of all matters great and small: Is it good for me? After concluding that it was, since many Trump supporters got their news from TikTok, he declined to enforce the law and later arranged for TikTok to be sold to a consortium of Trump cronies.

Hot rhetoric notwithstanding, Trump has persistently retreated from substantive policies that would have signaled actual seriousness to China. Boasting of his "great relationship" with Xi, Trump froze a planned $14 billion arms package to Taiwan, signaled that he might lift sanctions on Chinese companies that bought Iranian oil and canceled defense talks with Taiwan. Though he didn't do it to please the Chinese strongman, Trump surely made Xi smile when he withdrew several carrier groups from the South China Sea to redeploy to the Middle East after launching his war on Iran.

On top of this pattern of laxity, the Nvidia story represents a direct betrayal of U.S. national security — one so enormous that you have to reach for fiction for analogies. A president has a mental health meltdown? A Chinese mole makes it to the Oval Office? For two years now, the world has been transfixed by the potential threat of AI. It's practically all we talk about. Everyone in the free world understands that in the race to dominate the industry, the U.S. and China are locked in competition. Perhaps the doomers are wrong to think the fate of humanity hangs in the balance, but at least we know that it's kind of important that with a technology so powerful that it might upend everything, it's better that the Chinese Communist Party not get ahead of us.

The advanced computer chips Nvidia manufactures are key to command and control, surveillance, the generation of deepfakes and much more. That's the risk that permitting export of those chips poses for national security. What was Trump's interest? Well, Nvidia powers the AI companies that are currently driving the stock market boom. Trump has personally invested between $13 million and $62 million in Nvidia stock, and he doubtless appreciated Jensen Huang's contribution of $25 million for the White House ballroom. So when Marco Rubio and Scott Bessent, the secretaries of state and the treasury, objected that Howard Lutnick, the secretary of commerce, is not enforcing export controls on Nvidia chips, it put Trump in a tough spot. On one hand, you have national security and the need to protect America from Chinese acquisition of the most sensitive technology in the world; on the other, you have Trump's personal fortune possibly increasing through Nvidia's success in selling to everyone, China included. It's a tough choice, right?

Trump is worse than weak. He is, and has always been, for sale. We didn't need the Nvidia scandal to prove this. If there is a conflict between Trump's personal interest in vacuuming up cash and the national interest, his personal interest will prevail. Every single time.

This week's summit provides yet another opportunity for Trump to hone his "great relationships" with the world's worst dictators. It's also an opportunity for the Democrats, who will soon gain the gavels in Congress, to reflect that they are the bulwark of national security now.

Mona Charen is policy editor of The Bulwark and host of the "Beg to Differ" podcast. Her book, "Hard Right: The GOP's Drift Toward Extremism," is available now.

Photo credit: Sou Jest at Unsplash

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

Mona Charen
About Mona Charen
Read More | RSS | Subscribe

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE...